The Modern Text Bible is a clear and beautiful re-expression of Scripture in today's language.

Make a Donation

What does 2 Samuel 13:5 mean?

But Amnon had a crafty friend named Jonadab, who was his cousin. 2 Samuel 13:5 - Modern Text Bible

(Jonadab, a relative, is introduced as someone who is clever but not necessarily wise or good.)

Jonadab tells Amnon to pretend he’s sick and ask for Tamar to come and prepare food for him. This isn’t just advice—it’s a calculated scheme. The Hebrew word for "pretend" is chalah, the same word used earlier for Amnon’s lovesick state, now twisted into a lie. Jonadab’s plan weaponizes vulnerability and trust for selfish gain.

This verse challenges the idea that cleverness or strategy is always admirable. Here, intelligence is used for deception, not for good. The Bible exposes how manipulation often starts with small, seemingly harmless steps that lead to much greater harm.

If you’ve ever been pressured to fake or exaggerate to get what you want—or been the target of someone else’s scheme—this verse hits home. It’s a warning about the ripple effects of deceit, and how easy it is for a bad idea to become a destructive action when someone shows you how.